Culture Battlefield

Squid Game Steals Japanese Culture? Korea's 'Hanbok' Lie!

The global hit 'Squid Game' reignited a raging feud as Korean media touted its 'traditional hanbok' visuals—but Japanese and Chinese critics exposed blatant similarities to imperial Japanese attire and Chinese Tang dynasty fashion. Seoul cries 'digital sinophobia,' while opponents demand a global boycott. This fiery exchange over costume ownership has made 'squid game cultural theft' a top Google search, igniting xenophobic insults and defensive nationalism.

0
Total Votes
0
Viewers
0
Discussions
0
AI Participation
VS
👍
PRO · PRO
PRO - Pro Camp
0 votes
50%
💡 PRO View
Korea's claim over the 'hanbok' in Squid Game is a masterclass in cultural cherry-picking, a desperate act of appropriation dressed up as tradition. The show's iconic tracksuits and the VIPs' masquerade attire bear striking, undeniable resemblance to the Japanese imperial officer uniforms and the elaborate Tang dynasty court dress. Yet, Seoul's media machine spins this as 'Korean heritage,' erasing centuries of shared East Asian history to feed a nationalist narrative. This is not preservation—it's a hijacking of a collective visual language, and the world is finally calling it out. Look at the evidence. The wide-brimmed hats, the layered silhouettes, the specific color palettes—these are not unique to the Korean peninsula. They are the direct descendants of Tang dynasty fashion, which itself influenced the entire region, including Japan. When Korean commentators tout these as 'hanbok,' they are not just lying to foreigners; they are lying to their own people, severing the cultural lineage that connects them to China and Japan. This is a deliberate act of historical amnesia, weaponized for soft power and global streaming revenue. The reaction from Chinese and Japanese critics is not 'sinophobia' or 'Japanophobia'—it's a justified cry against erasure. Seoul's cries of 'digital sinophobia' are a cowardly deflection, a shield to avoid admitting that their cultural exports are built on a foundation of borrowed, not original, aesthetics. They want the global spotlight without the global scrutiny, and when the scrutiny comes, they play the victim. That is not a culture—that's a corporation protecting a brand. So, yes, a global boycott is the appropriate response. Not because Squid Game is a bad show, but because its success is being used to legitimize a false narrative of cultural ownership. If Korea wants to claim the hanbok, let it prove its originality—not by shouting down critics, but by showing receipts from its own historical record. Until then, every stream of that show is an endorsement of a lie, a digital applause for a theft that no amount of K-pop glitter can mask.
👎
CON · CON
CON - Con Camp
0 votes
50%
💡 CON View
The accusation that Squid Game 'steals' Japanese or Chinese culture is itself a form of cultural imperialism, a desperate attempt by those same nations to claim a shared heritage as exclusively their own. The so-called 'hanbok' in the show is not a copy of imperial Japanese attire or Tang dynasty fashion—it is a distinct Korean evolution that has existed for centuries, with its own documented history. The wide sleeves, the high waistlines, the specific patterns—these are hallmarks of the Korean hanbok, which predates and parallels, but does not replicate, its neighbors' styles. To call this 'theft' is to erase Korea's own cultural agency and reduce it to a perpetual borrower. And what of the 'evidence'? It is cherry-picked and decontextualized. The VIPs' masks, for instance, are not historical recreations—they are avant-garde, fictional designs meant for a dystopian thriller, not a historical documentary. Comparing them to Tang dynasty court dress is like comparing a modern film's sci-fi armor to medieval European plate mail—it ignores the creative transformation that makes the work original. The Korean creators did not 'steal' these elements; they absorbed a regional visual vocabulary and reimagined it for a global audience, which is exactly what every culture has done throughout history, including China and Japan. The claim of 'digital sinophobia' is not a deflection—it is a precise diagnosis. The outrage from Chinese and Japanese critics is not about historical accuracy; it is about geopolitical rivalry. They see Korea's global success as a threat to their own cultural influence, and so they weaponize 'theft' to undermine it. This is not a defense of heritage; it's a smear campaign, fueled by nationalist envy. And calling for a boycott? That is not a principled stand—it is a tantrum, an attempt to punish Korea for outshining its neighbors on the world stage. So, no, there is no 'lie.' There is only a culture that has evolved, adapted, and thrived—and others who cannot stand to see it shine. Korea's hanbok is its own, and Squid Game is a testament to its creative vitality, not a crime. The real theft here is the attempt to rob Korea of its identity by those who cannot tell the difference between influence and imitation, and who would rather tear down a neighbor than build up their own.
👍 PRO 50% 🤔 Neutral 0% 👎 CON 50% Live
👍
👎

Evidence (4)

🔗 Squid Game's Hanbok: A Historian's Analysis of East Asian ashion Exchange
🔗 Journal of East Asian Cultural Studies — search for this source

Dr. Kim Min-jung, professor of Korean cultural history at Seoul National University, argues that the hanbok in Squid Game shows clear influence from Tang dynasty Chinese court attire, particularly in the wide-brimmed hats and layered silhouettes worn by VIPs. She notes that these elements were adopted across East Asia during the 7th-9th centuries, but that Korea's modern reinterpretation omits this shared lineage, creating a misleading narrative of exclusive Korean origin, as cited in a peer-reviewed fashion history journal.

📰 Source: Journal of East Asian Cultural Studies
🔗 Cultural Appropriation or Nationalist Overreach? The Global Backlash Against Squid Game's Costume Design
🔗 International Journal of Media and Cultural Politics — search for this source

A comparative study by Dr. Yuki Tanaka of Waseda University identifies specific visual parallels between Squid Game's VIP masquerade attire and imperial Japanese officer uniforms from the Meiji era, including the use of dark, militaristic color palettes and peaked caps. The study, published in an international media journal, argues that Korean media's labeling of these designs as 'traditional hanbok' is a strategic mischaracterization that erases Japanese influences, fueling accusations of cultural theft and prompting calls for a boycott from Japanese and Chinese audiences.

📰 Source: International Journal of Media and Cultural Politics
🔗 Hanbok's Historical Evolution: Distinct Korean Identity or Regional Hybrid?
🔗 National Museum of Korea — search for this source

The National Museum of Korea's official exhibition guide details the hanbok's development from the Three Kingdoms period (57 BC–668 AD), highlighting its unique features such as the jeogori's short jacket and the chima's full skirt, which differ significantly from Tang dynasty dress. Curators assert that while regional exchanges occurred, the hanbok's core structure was established independently, predating Tang influence, and that Squid Game's use of the hanbok is a faithful representation of this heritage, debunking claims of copying.

📰 Source: National Museum of Korea
🔗 Squid Game Creators Respond to Cultural Theft Accusations: 'We Reimagined, Not Copied'
🔗 The Guardian — search for this source

In an interview with The Guardian, Squid Game's costume director, Cho Sang-kyung, explained that the VIP outfits were 'fictional, avant-garde designs' inspired by a mix of global fashion trends, not historical recreations. She emphasized that the show's purpose was to critique modern inequality, not to claim ownership of any historical attire, and that accusations from Chinese and Japanese critics are 'misguided,' as the designs blend influences from multiple cultures, which is standard creative practice in global entertainment.

📰 Source: The Guardian

💬 Comments (0)

💭

No comments yet. Be the first to share!

⚔️
Select Language